Your Honor Season 2 Review – A good ending elevates a story with little spark

Season 1

Season 2

Episode Guide

Episode 1 – | Review Score – 3/5
Episode 2 – | Review Score – 3/5
Episode 3 – | Review Score – 4/5
Episode 4 – | Review Score – 4/5
Episode 5 – | Review Score – 4/5
Episode 6 – | Review Score – 2.5/5
Episode 7 – | Review Score – 3/5
Episode 8 – | Review Score – 3/5
Episode 9 – | Review Score – 2.5/5
Episode 10 – | Review Score – 4.5/5



Your Honor’s maiden season became Showtime’s most-watched show of all time. It broke viewership records left and right and eventually got its justified renewal for a second season. After watching the complete season, one can speculate as to whether the decision to do so was the network’s or the creative brains’.

Bryan Cranston’s casual revelation of the show ending on a podcast points towards the former but even more so, the season itself is the biggest evidence of that being the reality. Season 2 finishes the saga with a mostly well-rounded conclusion to character arcs and subplots. Committed viewers can take respite in how things ended but the journey to the end feels tedious and uninspired.

Season 1 was a gripping and intense affair that explored the themes of justice, morality, and family in a compelling narrative. The series followed the story of a respected judge, Michael Desiato (played by Bryan Cranston), whose life is turned upside down when his son is involved in a hit-and-run accident that kills a member of a powerful crime family.

As Michael tries to protect his son and navigate the legal system, he finds himself making a series of difficult and morally ambiguous decisions that threaten to unravel his reputation and his family’s safety. The show’s tense pacing, nuanced character development, and intricate plot twists kept viewers on the edge of their seats, while its themes of power, corruption, and the complexities of the justice system raise thought-provoking questions about the nature of right and wrong.

Season 2 picked up from the sensational end of season 1 where Adam was killed by Eugene Jones. That triggered the chain of events in this season which spirals in an uncontrollable fashion for most characters.

No one seems to be truly in control and that keeps things open for a while. Even then, the show’s plot moves towards a largely predictable end, although the final two episodes are an aberration in some senses. One can perhaps excuse the creative personnel as the intentions for season 2 might have led to the final output. If you consider the first season as the setup, the second season is deliberate and deals with less confronting decisions but more introspective philosophical questions.

While season 1 forced us to confront the difficult questions of how we balance the demands of justice with the ties of love and loyalty that bind us to our families, season 2 takes a different approach. Although the philosophical quotient is never clearly established, resulting in the absence of a consistent thematic web and motifs, season 2 veers towards a renewed understanding of family and bonds beyond those contours.

There is a strong feeling of respecting the status quo and not completely disrupting the scales of power. Bryan Cranston and Michal Stuhlbarg (Jimmy Baxter) have some chilling moments together. The latter does not seem uncomfortable at all outside his archetype role and both actors present different versions of themselves from season 1, which is a real victory.

Andrene Ward-Hamond gets an opportunity to experiment in a more fully realized Big Mo in season 2. She makes the most of it by bringing both strength and vulnerability to the character. Her portrayal rests at a delicate spot between the spectrum of power and emotions.

However, Lilly Kay (Fia) falls a little short of fulfilling Fia’s transition. Her emotions feel placid and repetitive, something that betrays the stellar writing for her character. Hope Davis was a clear standout among the cast by contrast, bringing Gina’s anger and traditionalism stoutly on screen and stands in a compelling contest to Jimmy’s modernist rationale.

What makes Your Honor such a compelling series is its ability to balance the demands of suspenseful storytelling with the complexities of its thematic material. But then again, one expected this season to emulate the former’s taut pacing. That spark is definitely missing here.

At the same time however, the series never loses sight of the emotional stakes at play, as Michael’s desperate attempts to protect his family lead him into ever deeper waters of corruption and deceit.

Ultimately, Your Honor is a powerful reminder of the importance of grappling with the difficult questions of justice and morality that confront us all in our lives. Through its richly drawn characters, gripping storytelling, and nuanced exploration of complex ethical themes, Your Honor stands as one of the most thought-provoking and compelling legal dramas of recent years overall. Unfortunately, season 2 is somewhat disappointing.

Feel Free To Check Out More Of Our TV Show Reviews Here!

  • Verdict - 6/10

Leave a comment