Emergence – Full Season 1 Review

Season 1

Episode Guide

Pilot -| Review Score – 3.5/5
Camera Wheelbarrow Tiger Pillow -| Review Score – 4/5
2 MG CU BID -| Review Score – 3.5/5
No Outlet -| Review Score – 3.5/5
RDZ9021 -| Review Score – 4/5
Mile Marker 14 -| Review Score – 3.5/5
Fatal Exception -| Review Score – 4/5
American Chestnut -| Review Score – 2.5/5
Where You Belong -| Review Score – 3/5
15 Years -| Review Score – 3.5/5
Applied Sciences -| Review Score – 2.5/5
Killshot Pt. 1 -| Review Score – 3/5
Killshot Pt. 2 -| Review Score – 3/5


Emergence is a show with a serious identity problem. Beginning as a mystery with elements of Stranger Things included, across the 13 episode story multiple antagonists and different angled plots have wrestled for control, resulting in a messy and oftentimes tonally confused narrative that’s failed to settle into a consistent rhythm. It’s frustrating too because the show has a lot of positives, including a diverse, likable cast and some nice twists along the way. The early season promise is subsequently squandered by one too many deviations from the main plot line, ending the series in a very different place than the one it began in.

The story begins with a good dose of mystery. A small child is found amongst wreckage on a beach with no knowledge of who she is and why she’s there. As powerful forces try to snatch her away, police chief Jo finds herself wrapped up a conspiracy that spans all the way through to powerful forces operating in the shadows. As the series progresses, we learn more about Piper and just who or what she is, before throwing in multiple plot twists, surprises and cliffhangers that over-eagerly charge through to the action-packed two-part finale.

The problem with this style of shock-factor storytelling is that consistency and pacing are lost, especially during a binge-watch rather than a week-to-week story. The season finale is tonally very different from the opening and while some may like the progression into action-packed thriller territory, the early season mystery and more methodical pace is what made the show such a good hook to begin with.

Thankfully the characters are one of the saving graces of the show. Allison Tolman is fantastic in her role as the police chief and alongside Alexa Swinton (who plays Piper) the two have a good chemistry that keeps this one ticking along nicely. The rest of the supporting players do well too and for that alone, Emergence is a fun ride while it lasts.

With a cliffhanger ending and no word on whether this will be renewed for a second season or not, it’s questionable that the show would leave things hanging the way it has – especially given how trigger happy some networks are over cancellations and low ratings. Despite that, Emergence is a good enough show to watch but not something that’s likely to ignite the mystery or thriller genre anytime soon.

It’s not a bad show per-se but it’s not a particularly great one either. Emergence’s story is one that dips into several different styles of storytelling until settling on light sci-fi, struggling to find a good balance and subsequently resulting in something very different from what it began as all those weeks ago. Perhaps with a second season this one will settle into a more consistent rhythm but for now, the first is a bit of a rocky road and one that not everyone will enjoy driving down.

Emergence is available to watch on ABC Network. Feel free to click here to check this show out!


Click Here To Go Back To Our TV Shows

  • Verdict - 5/10

1 thought on “Emergence – Full Season 1 Review”

  1. Emergence fully held my interest until ep. 6., Mile Marker 14, then since the action was no longer worth sitting through an excess of tv commercials I have binge watched eps. 7 thru 9, Where You Belong, on Hulu (ad free) and right when ep 10 started it was apparent that Piper might not come back during ep 10 so I found (SPOILER ALERT) the shows Wiki which told me the show was only 13 eps total and Piper was not scripted to be a visible actor for the remaining episodes and since the shows ratings had seriously dropped by the end of ep 9 it made me think there probably won’t be a Season 2 so I won’t be back unless I hear the network hired some much better script writers and maybe then the show might bounce back to it’s initial top ratings.

    Sorry I dropped out at the start of ep 10 but with Piper I doubt it could get any better.

Leave a comment