Survivors of the Flux
Episode 5 of Doctor Who: Flux begins with the Doctor freeing herself from stone. She’s inexplicably no longer a Weeping Angel and her friends are lost. When the Doctor awakens, she finds an Ood scanning her down. She’s in Division.
Anyway, Yaz is in Mexico with Dan and Professor Jericho. The year is 1904 and they drop into a temple and uncover a special pot. And the next scene, they’re in Constantinople. Apparently this pot Yaz has taken is able to decipher the exact date the world is going to end. It’s been 3 years since they’ve seen the Doctor and after finding out a date (5th December. Get it? When the season comes to an end?) they’re forced to flee from a rogue explosion, planting by an assassin.
As they board a boat and head off, the trio are blindsided by an assassin. After thwarting him, an adaptive hologram (aka exposition dump) from the Doctor helps to understand a little of what’s going on. Apparently there’s going to be a big battle for the Earth, off the back of the Flux destroying the universe, and they need to find out the date that will occur. If not, then things are going to get very ugly.
Eventually the gang make it to Nepal where they meet a hermit with 3 words for them “Fetch your dog.” The gang realize what this mean and leave a message for Karvanista. He inexplicably manages to see this same message from his console, and growls that he’s not able to time travel. So how is he seeing the message? And what was the point in this whole mission then? No time, onward to more exposition!
We then jump across to 1958 England, where a guy called Prentis is out hunting. He’s offered the opportunity of setting up a task-force by a mysterious guy we later find out is colloquially called “Grand Serpent.” This task-force happens to be UNIT, which we see in another individual scene in 1963.
The Division seem to have invaded UNIT, as this slippery serpent continues to influence UNIT from the inside, killing off key members of the group. Kate though realizes they’ve been invaded as the year reaches 2021 and confronts him, promising to get payback and call in a favour to the Doctor if he’s not careful.
Nestled in the midst of all this is yet more exposition with the Doctor and the leader of Division, It turns out Division actually began back on Gallifrey as a group to ensure the safety of our galaxy.
The Operatives get involved in civilization and interfere across space and time. Apparently thy recruit all different creatures and species, but they’re also not in the universe either. They’re outside this Universe, or “Universe 1” as she calls it. With this Universe about to be destroyed, they’re moving onto a new one. Kinda like that big speech in The Matrix Reloaded, eh?
Anyway, apparently the Doctor is a virus and this woman happens to be Tecteun, the woman the Doctor used to call Mother. It seems like thee Flux is converging onto Earth, as the ultimate apex of destruction. It’s the final place where the Flux will end
. This is ironic because in episode 1, if you’ll remember, the Flux wave showed up moving from outside the solar system through the planets. So that means Venus and Mercury would be hit after the Earth right?
Anyway, it turns out Tecteun has one of those pocket watches that hold more of the Doctor’s memories. She has a choice – she can either return to the dying Universe and try to save her friends or she can rejoin Division with her memories restored. Tecteun tries to persuade her, urging the Doctor to press on and explore this second universe, which could hold her origin. The Doctor chooses to save her friends of course.
Meanwhile in 2021, Karvanista tracks down the rogue Lupari ship which happens to be Bel. Vinder meanwhile, starts talking to himself, finding all the missing townsfolk. Swarm and Azure are there, using them as a power source to increase the time-force. When Vinder is spotted, Passenger arrives and blasts him with a teleport wave, transporting him to a strange area where Diane, Dan’s date, happens to be.
Back in 1904, Dan, Yaz and the Professor head back on the boat and find themselves bumping into Joseph Williamson, the tunnel-expert from the opening scenes in episode 1. Dan believes he’s the key to all this so off they go, to Liverpool in 1904. They head there, reconvene with Joseph and descend into the tunnels.
Apparently he’s found a number of different doorways that lead off to different places. He outright mentions the Flux and what it’s caused, with Tunnel 9 in particular a no-go zone.
However, Sontarans suddenly return, bursting through the tunnels. They also board the Lupari ship too, all influenced by the Grand Serpent who promises they won’t be stopped this time.
A scene with Azure and Swarm are how this episode ends, as they show up at Division, kill Tecteun and prepare to go after the Doctor.
The Episode Review
Survivors of the Flux feels like a drunk Chris Chibnall trying (and failing) to emulate a Stephen Moffat script. I’m actually quite shocked at how bad this episode is. Now, forget the Timeless Child stuff for a second, the entire episode bounces around like a hyperactive child, exuding exposition across a 50 minute time-frame with very little rhyme or reason.
The Doctor’s separate story with Tecteun needs exposition, I understands that. Yaz, the Professor and Dan just randomly pop up in 1904 and travel across the world to find a McGuffin pot with a random, inconsequential date and painting the floor for Karvanista…who can’t even jump back and find them is pure nonsense.
So instead they stumble upon a lucky break when Joseph Williamson, the random miner from Liverpool, activates a teleport that sees him board the exact right ship, at the exact right time, in the exact right year to stumble upon our rabble of characters, giving them the next piece of the puzzle. Couldn’t they have just started with that? What happened to our characters in those 3 years? There’s a nice moment with Yaz and the hologram but why not expand on that? Why is Dan just the comedy centerpiece here? Why not expand his character?
Then you get the interspersed UNIT stuff, which honestly has had very little set-up and just seems to come out of nowhere. Even worse, it actually makes for a narrative rife with plot holes.
If the Grand Serpent’s plan involves the Sontarans taking over…why not get involved in the Poison Sky story-line? I mean, the Sontarans have pretty much won at that point and all it would take is some smarts too keep the Doctor away.
And that’s before mentioning the holes involving a rogue TARDIS inside Unit. So what happened during the Troughton/Pertwee era then? Pertwee in particular was grounded the entire time and he never once saw nor thought about using this Tardis? And how did the Brigadier and the Doctor not know about the Grand Serpent, given he’s been running the show all this time? These sort of questions just show how messy the scripts have been this year – with this episode the epitome of bad.
I’ve been back and forth on this series, but between last week’s decent Angel episode and episode 2’s better-paced Sontaran stand-alone, everything in between has been awful. In fact, it feels like that scene in The Dark Knight when Joker burns stacks of cash just to show he only cares about chaos. And thus, that typifies Chibnall’s run. Not with a big triumphant fanfare but with large flames destroying everything that’s come before.
Thankfully Chibnall is nearly gone and when he finally disappears, let’s hope Russell T. Davies can build this show back up from the smoldering ruins that have been left behind.
Previous Episode |
Next Episode |
You can read our full season review for Doctor Who: Flux here! |
|
-
Episode Rating
(1)
I can’t agree more. These last episodes are not making a whole lot of sense and are difficult to follow. Someone should have taken the writer in hand and had him get his act together. After reading these scripts, they may be the reason Jodie Whittaker is ready to throw in the towel on her role as Dr. Who! She has been wonderful!
I’ve surprisingly enjoyed about 60% of Flux up until this point. But the 5th episode didn’t really live up to some of what came before. I like strong female characters and Yaz genuinely had a few snippets of scenes which in isolation I find very cool. But many scenes seemed overplayed to the point that she’s perfect and amazing and all relevant male characters around her are just buffoons. I don’t mind comic relief. Many people are that. But it feels so forced that all male characters are idiots around Yaz. I’d like at least one more character who was in any sense reasonable. That was my first issue in the first 15 minutes.
One more issue I had with Yaz and Companions is that their historical adventures were all offscreen. No exploration of the times. Just a brief montage of Indiana Jones fast travel with map backdrop.
The whole thing with the big snakey boi made no sense to me on any causality abiding suspension of disbelief. I’m thinking either: 1) He became a person in high position and didn’t do anything to alter the course of history for the past 5 centuries (did Lethbridge-Stewart say 5?) bar 1 or 2 definitive meetings (I assume he had some offscreen missions to justify the meetings in the first place) And then suddenly snakey boi is talking with Lethbridge-Stewart? Like you said in the review, how did the slithery one not slither his way in Poison-Sky? Or literally any other time? Sontarans would be convenient, but did they say it had to involve them specifically? Or 2) If he just jumped in time like Lethbridge-Stewart suggested, has it been like a week or a day for him? Then if so, was the president of the first line of defence against extra-terrestrial threats just been vanished for few hundred years at a time and nobody needed to refer back to him or replace him with someone who shows up to work?
Finally going onto the Division story line, personally it hardly makes any sense to me.
1) The flux swallowed 99.99999999999% of the universe in the firs ep and it’s been taking its time with the minute region of space that is our local group? 2) Why would Tecteun want the Doctor to join her? Wasn’t the doctor a liability? To some point, maybe, but how is the doctor going to un-collapse the universe? (Collapse sounds pretty irreversible. Ah sorry wibbly wobbly timey whimey reversing of polarity magic) It seems like the Doctor is a non threat this late in the story so why give her the opportunity to fight back from the inside of division? And wasn’t the point of flux to get rid of the doctor (as an extension of the universe she was in?)
I don’t know. The villains feel fake, giving free passes so that the goodies can win. The lore ruining mysteries of Timeless children was just given freely with little tension build-up or cause…. Exposition dumps given like an afterthought. And the omnipotent creatures that were doing stuff through last 5 episodes seem so disconnected and yet do anything when they want without much rhyme or reason.
Ps isn’t that a void ship?
What’s the difference between “another universe” and “parallel universe”. I thought the idea of a multiverse is that all other universes are parallel to some degree.
It’s possible I misunderstood some parts or missed something. But the episode as a whole just doesn’t add up to anything. 2/10