Best Mystery Games of All Time | TheReviewGeek Recommends

There are a lot of video games out there and in this era of mobile and home-based gaming, the choices have never been greater. So how do you cut through the noise and find the “Best of” for any chosen topic?

Well, we’re here to help celebrate and shine a spotlight on some of the latest, greatest, and unforgettable games through the years.

For our ongoing series of articles depicting the best video games, our attention this time turns to mystery games. From courtroom drama to supernatural investigations, you have a lot of games to whet your appetite.

Of course, if we’ve missed any of your favorites, feel free to comment below and we’ll get them added on!

Phoenix Wright: Ace Attorney

Phoenix Wright: Ace Attorney is a fantastic mystery game that offers players an immersive experience as they step into the shoes of a defense attorney. With its engaging storytelling, clever puzzles, and memorable characters, it stands out as one of the best games in the genre.

The game tasks you with solving countless murder cases by investigating crime scenes and presenting evidence in court. It weaves together its intricate narrative with surprising twists and turns.

Each case presents a unique mystery for players to unravel, with multiple layers of suspense and intrigue. The game excels at forcing players to utilize their own brain power to analyze evidence, cross-examine witnesses, and find contractions in their testimonies.

With its challenging puzzles, well-rounded cast, and nice visual aesthetics, Phoenix Wright: Ace Attorney is a rousing mystery series that keeps you hooked. 

Ghost Trick: Phantom Detective

Ghost Trick: Phantom Detective comes from the same mind that brought you the Ace Attorney series. In it, players control Sissel, a ghost who can possess and manipulate objects. He uses his powers to alter events, solve puzzles, and influence characters’ actions to unravel the game’s multiple mysteries. One case has you possess a fan to create a breeze that will extinguish a fire to save someone. 

The game’s clever use of these mechanics keeps players hooked and constantly thinking about how to best use Sissel’s powers. The plot contains unexpected twists, shocking revelations, and moments of suspense that keep players hooked from start to finish.

Plus with its excellent visual style and sound design, Ghost Trick: Phantom Detective is a great mystery title that’s worth playing. 

Return of Obra Dinn

Return of Obra Dinn is an exceptional mystery game that captivates players with its unique gameplay mechanics, intriguing storyline, and immersive atmosphere.

The game puts players in the shoes of an insurance investigator tasked with unraveling the crew and passengers’ fate aboard the abandoned ship. Obra Dinn excels at creating fun gameplay mechanics. 

Players receive a magical pocket watch that allows them to witness specific moments leading to a character’s death. This freeze-frame mechanic encourages players to study the frozen scenes, noting details and clues to piece together the victim’s identity and what led to their demise.

On top of having a distinct monochromatic art style, Return of Obra Dinn is a must-play and brilliant mystery game. 


Soma is a phenomenal mystery title that immerses players in a thought-provoking and atmospheric narrative. As you delve into the depths of an underwater research facility, you’ll unravel complex and intriguing mysteries featuring audio logs and rich character interactions.

This game’s layered narrative raises thought-provoking questions about identity, consciousness, and human nature. Furthermore, Soma shines with its handling of intricate puzzles. Players will encounter numerous puzzles, ranging from deciphering codes to manipulating machinery to progress in the game. These puzzles require gamers to think critically and observe their environments for clues.

With its atmospheric world and clever puzzle design, Soma’s sure to impress any diehard mystery fanatic. 

Her Story

Her Story is a unique mystery game that places players in the role of a detective. You must unravel a complex case through a series of video clips. The game presents an intriguing story and challenges players to piece together the truth by exploring an extensive database of interview footage. As players watch more video clips and uncover additional data, they delve deeper into the game’s mystery. 

Her Story’s fragmented nature creates a sense of suspense and intrigue. Players will appreciate how this game allows them to form their own conclusions and interpret scenarios differently from others. It doesn’t provide explicit answers, leaving room for multiple theories and perspectives. If you’re okay with that, then Her Story will interest you. 

L.A. Noire

L.A. Noire is an interesting game from RockStar’s catalogue. Where other titles had you breaking the law and rules, this 0ne places you in the role of a detective who goes around solving crimes. Nonetheless, it stands out because of its grounded portrayal of investigation, innovative interrogation mechanics, and immersive storytelling. 

As you play through L.A. Noire, you’ll thoroughly examine crime scenes, gather intel, and interview witnesses and suspects to advance through each case. The attention to detail in recreating the 1940s era is evident in RockStar’s approach with this title’s interactions and dialogue. The narrative is brimming with many twists, turns, and morally ambiguous characters to further engage audiences.

With its great interrogative gameplay mechanics and noire aesthetic, L.A. Noire is an underrated gem that deserves your attention. 

What Remains of Edith Finch

What Remains of Edith Finch is an exceptional mystery game that captivates players with its unique storytelling and immersive exploration elements. The game sets players on a journey to uncover the mysteries surrounding the tragic deaths of the Finch family members. Each death is presented as a distinct and interactive vignette, allowing players to step into each family member’s shoes. The story weaves these individual stories together and gradually reveals the secrets and tragic that have plagued this family for eons.

The gameplay is immersive and fun. You’ll enjoy scouring the area to search for clues and artifacts. These will provide you with insight into the lives of the deceased family member, adding to your engagement with the title.

If you’re looking for a game with great puzzle design and tension, What Remains of Edith Finch is worth checking out. 

The Wolf Among Us

The Wolf Among Us is a stellar mystery game developed by Telltale Games. It excels in its masterful storytelling and suspenseful atmosphere, helping it stand out in the mystery genre. In it, you control Bigby Wolf, the sheriff of Fabletown, as he investigates a series of murders that threaten to reveal this secret community of fairytale creatures. 

As Bigby, you’ll unravel a complex web of lies, deceit, and political intrigue, Each decision you make has consequences, leading to multiple branching paths and endings. This will entice players to replay The Wolf Among Us several times while giving them a sense of agency.

In addition to having well-developed supporting cast members who’ll add to your immersion in the world, The Wolf Among Us is a nice mystery game that should entertain you. 

Paradise Killer

Paradise Killer is an outstanding mystery game. It has a great open-world design, an enigmatic narrative, and intricate investigation mechanics. In it, players control Lady Love Dies, an investigator tasked with solving a series of murders on the idyllic island of Paradise.

The game allows players to explore the island, uncover clues, and interrogate suspects to determine the truth behind crimes. Furthermore, the game contains phenomenal world-building and engaging characters. Paradise Island is a fascinating setting, filled with vibrant landscapes and mysterious lore. As players explore the island, they’ll enjoy speaking with its different characters, each with their own motivations and secrets.

In addition to having fabulous scenarios where you utilize your deduction skills to analyze crimes, Paradise Killer is a remarkable mystery title that’s worth adding to your gaming catalogue. 

Disco Elysium

Disco Elysium is a masterfully-crafted RPG game that has you explore a barren landscape. During your travels, you’ll interrogate numerous characters and solve crimes. Unlike most detective-themed endeavors, this one gives you the chance to become a horrid person. This level of agency allows players to forge personalized experiences with the game, making it more enticing to play. 

The game touches upon rich political and mature topics that’ll appeal to critical-thinking crowds. Although solving cases will be your primary objective, players can look forward to participating in random mischief. From singing songs to intimidating random NPCs, you’ll have a blast playing this RPG. Give it a shot if you’re looking for a deep yet fun gem to play. 

So, there we have it, our pick for the best mystery video games through the years!

What do you think of our picks? Do you agree? Are there any notable omissions? Let us know in the comments below!

Feel Free To Check Out More Video Game Recommendations Here!


Leave a comment